SEO & GEO

SEO Audit Checklist: A Step-by-Step Website Audit

10 min read Updated: Czytaj po polsku
SEO Audit Checklist: A Step-by-Step Website Audit

An SEO audit is a structured review of a website that answers three questions: can Google crawl and index it, does Google understand what each page is about, and does the content answer customers’ questions better than the competition? A good audit doesn’t end with 300 warnings exported from a tool — it ends with a short list of fixes ranked by their impact on traffic and revenue. Below is the 9-step checklist we work through on business websites and online shops.

What is an SEO audit and when should you run one?

An SEO audit is a technical and content diagnosis of a website from a search engine’s point of view. It covers indexing, URL and link structure, content, performance, structured data and off-site signals. Unlike ongoing SEO work, it has a clear start and finish: it ends with a report and an implementation plan.

Run one in four situations:

  • before and after a migration or redesign — a new CMS, domain or URL structure is the most common cause of sudden traffic drops;
  • after a traffic drop that seasonality doesn’t explain;
  • before starting an SEO campaign, so you’re not building content on broken foundations;
  • periodically — a full review once a year and a quick Search Console check every month.

Which tools do you need?

Tool What it’s for in an audit Cost
Google Search Console Indexing, queries and pages, field Core Web Vitals, links, Generative AI performance report Free
PageSpeed Insights Per-URL performance: real-user data plus a lab test Free
Screaming Frog SEO Spider Full-site crawl: status codes, titles, headings, canonicals, redirects Free up to 500 URLs, then an annual licence
Rich Results Test Structured data validation Free
Google Analytics 4 Organic traffic, engagement, conversions Free
Bing Webmaster Tools Indexing and errors in Bing Free

For a small business site, the free tools are enough. For an online shop with thousands of products, an unlimited crawler is a must.

Step 1. Crawling and indexing

This is the foundation: if Google can’t crawl or index your pages, nothing else in the audit matters. Check:

  1. robots.txt — it shouldn’t block important sections or CSS and JS files, and it should point to your sitemap. As Google’s documentation puts it, robots.txt is not a way to keep pages out of Google: a blocked URL can still appear in results, just without a description. To keep a page out of the index, use noindex or a password.
  2. Meta robots and the X-Robots-Tag header — make sure no staging noindex made it to production.
  3. XML sitemap — only canonical URLs returning 200. A single sitemap holds at most 50,000 URLs or 50 MB uncompressed; Google ignores priority and changefreq, and only uses lastmod when it’s consistently accurate (Google: build a sitemap).
  4. One canonical host — http, https, www and non-www should all 301 to a single version.
  5. Status codes and redirects — URLs returning 4xx aren’t indexed, and persistent 5xx errors slow crawling and eventually drop URLs from the index. Googlebot follows up to 10 redirect hops; a 301 is a strong signal to Google, a 302 a weak one (Google: HTTP status codes). Collapse chains into a single hop.

Then work through the Page indexing report in Search Console. The most common statuses (Search Console Help) and how to read them:

Search Console status What it usually means What to do
Crawled – currently not indexed Google has seen the content but hasn’t indexed it yet; not always a problem For key pages: strengthen the content and internal links
Discovered – currently not indexed Google knows the URL but postponed crawling, often to avoid overloading the server Check server performance; cut unnecessary URLs (filters, parameters)
Duplicate without user-selected canonical The same content lives at several URLs Add a canonical or a redirect
Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user Conflicting canonical signals Align canonicals, internal links and the sitemap
Soft 404 The page returns 200 but looks empty or broken Return 404/410 or add real content
Server error (5xx) The server didn’t respond properly Hosting, caching, resource limits

Only worry about crawl budget on large sites. Google’s rough guide is sites with more than a million unique pages changing weekly, or more than 10,000 pages changing daily (Google: managing crawl budget). A typical business site just needs a current sitemap and an eye on the indexing report.

Step 2. Rendering and the mobile version

Google indexes and ranks the mobile version of your content, crawled with its smartphone agent (Google: mobile-first indexing). In practice, that means three checks:

  • the mobile version has the same content, structured data and robots meta tags as desktop;
  • content in tabs and accordions is fine as long as it’s in the markup — but anything loaded only after a click or typed input may never be indexed;
  • in URL Inspection, view the rendered HTML and confirm the main content, links and headings are there.

For JavaScript-heavy interfaces, and especially 3D and WebGL websites, this step is non-negotiable: a 3D scene tells a crawler nothing, so text, headings and links must exist in plain HTML.

Step 3. Site architecture and internal linking

  • Click depth — our rule of thumb is that service pages, categories and best-sellers sit no more than three clicks from the homepage.
  • Orphan pages — compare crawled URLs with your sitemap and GA4 landing pages. A page with no internal links pointing to it looks unimportant to Google.
  • Anchor text — descriptive (“ecommerce website design”), not “read more” or “click here”.
  • Links to errors — update every internal link pointing at a 404 or through a redirect so it hits the final URL.
  • URLs — short, readable, no session IDs; keep shop filters and sorting from spawning thousands of duplicates.
  • Language versions — if you run several languages, check hreflang. Each version must list itself and every other version, and the links must be reciprocal, or Google ignores them (Google: localised versions).

Step 4. On-page: titles, descriptions, headings

Your crawler will flag missing, duplicate and “too long” titles. Read that list with care. Google sets no length limit for titles — it truncates them to fit the screen — and it may build the title link from other elements such as the H1, anchor text or WebSite structured data. Consistency matters more than character counts.

  • every page has a unique, descriptive title without keyword stuffing;
  • the H1 is the most prominent title on the page and matches the <title>;
  • the meta description earns the click — even if Google sometimes swaps in a passage from the page;
  • images have descriptive alt text and file names;
  • cannibalisation: in the Performance report, filter by an important query and open the Pages tab. If several URLs rotate for the same query, merge them or clearly separate their topics.

Step 5. Content quality and E-E-A-T

Google suggests judging content through three questions: who created it (bylines and author bios), how it was made (including whether AI was involved) and why — primarily to help people? (Google: helpful, reliable, people-first content). Of the four elements of E-E-A-T — experience, expertise, authoritativeness, trust — trust matters most, although E-E-A-T is not a single ranking factor in itself.

In a content audit we mainly look for:

  • thin pages — empty categories, tag archives, product descriptions copied from the manufacturer;
  • gaps — customer questions your site doesn’t answer but competitors do;
  • missing proof of experience — case studies, photos, data, named authors;
  • fake freshness — Google explicitly lists changing dates without substantial content changes as a sign of search-engine-first content.

Step 6. Performance: Core Web Vitals

Metric What it measures Good score
LCP (Largest Contentful Paint) When the largest content element renders 2.5 s or less
INP (Interaction to Next Paint) How quickly the page responds to interactions 200 ms or less
CLS (Cumulative Layout Shift) Layout stability while loading 0.1 or less

According to web.dev, thresholds are assessed at the 75th percentile of page loads, separately for mobile and desktop. Start with real-user data in Search Console’s Core Web Vitals report — it groups URLs by template, so you’ll see straight away whether, say, every product page is affected. Lab tests are for diagnosing causes. We cover fixes in detail in Core Web Vitals: how to speed up your website.

Step 7. Structured data

  • for a business: Organization or LocalBusiness, consistent with your Google Business Profile;
  • for a shop: Product with price and availability, plus BreadcrumbList;
  • for a blog: Article with author and publication date;
  • every property must match what’s visible on the page — check with the Rich Results Test.

Watch out for stale advice. According to Google’s documentation changelog, FAQ rich results stopped appearing in Search on 7 May 2026, following earlier retirements including HowTo and several niche types. If an audit tool tells you to add FAQPage markup “for a rich result”, that advice is out of date. We explain which schema types still make sense in our article on structured data, llms.txt and robots.txt for AI crawlers.

  • in Search Console’s Links report, review the top linking sites and anchor texts;
  • find URLs with external links that now return 404 — usually migration leftovers — and 301 them to the closest relevant page;
  • for local businesses: a complete Google Business Profile and consistent name, address and phone number across directories.

An audit in 2026 can’t ignore AI answers. Check:

  • the Generative AI performance report in Search Console — available to all sites since 31 August 2026 — which shows which pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode;
  • the “Search generative AI” setting — make sure the site hasn’t been opted out by accident;
  • robots.txt and CDN rules — make sure they don’t block AI search crawlers you want traffic from (e.g. OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot);
  • whether key pages answer customer questions directly in their opening sentences.

How do you prioritise after an audit?

Tool reports treat a critical error and a cosmetic one the same way. That’s why we sort every finding into one of four groups:

Priority Examples Why
Critical — fix now noindex on key pages, robots.txt blocks, 5xx errors, missing redirects after a migration Pages drop out of results or lose traffic
High Duplicates and cannibalisation, poor Core Web Vitals on key templates, orphaned service pages Direct impact on rankings and conversion
Medium Titles and descriptions, redirect chains, structured data, content gaps Better CTR and better understanding of the site
Low Meta description length, alt text on decorative images Housekeeping — fix when convenient

When we started on shadowbrand.pl in July 2026, the domain had next to no search visibility. Search Console now shows 52,200 impressions and 1,680 clicks at a 3.2% CTR, with daily impressions reaching 1,200–1,600 in November. On new domains the audit is shorter but matters more: indexing and architecture mistakes caught at launch never get the chance to do damage.

What should a good audit report include?

  1. A one-page summary for the business owner: the three to five biggest problems and what they cost the business.
  2. A task list with priorities, effort estimates and owners (developer, copywriter, marketing).
  3. Evidence: Search Console screenshots, example URLs, crawl exports.
  4. A baseline: clicks, impressions, indexing and Core Web Vitals on audit day, so you can compare results in three months.

Want someone to run this checklist for you and hand back a ready-to-use fix plan? We’ll carry out an SEO and GEO audit of your website or shop and can implement the fixes too — tell us about your project.

Frequently asked questions

How often should you run an SEO audit?

Run a full audit once a year and always before and after a migration, CMS change or redesign. In between, a monthly look at the Page indexing, Performance and Core Web Vitals reports in Search Console is usually enough.

Is a free online SEO audit tool enough?

As a starting point, yes; as a diagnosis, no. Automated tools flag symptoms, but they don't know your business goals, can't set priorities and often report things that don't matter, such as meta description length. The value of an audit lies in interpretation and an action plan.

How much does an SEO audit cost?

It depends on the number of pages, the type of site (a business site or a shop with faceted navigation), the CMS, the number of language versions and whether the audit covers a migration or implementing the fixes. At OrbitBuilder we quote each audit individually after a short call and a look at the site.

Does blocking a page in robots.txt remove it from Google?

No. Google states that robots.txt isn't a mechanism for keeping pages out of Search — a blocked URL can still appear in results, just without a description. To keep a page out of the index, use a noindex meta tag or password-protect it.

What should you check after a site migration?

Check 301 redirects from old URLs to their equivalents (ideally one-to-one), make sure no staging noindex went live, submit the new sitemap in Search Console, verify canonicals and hreflang, and look for externally linked URLs that now return 404. Watch the Page indexing report and traffic to key pages for several weeks.

Is FAQPage markup still worth adding?

Not for rich results — Google stopped showing FAQ rich results in Search on 7 May 2026. A questions-and-answers section still helps readers and structures your content, so keeping the FAQ section itself on the page is worthwhile.

Sources

  1. web.dev — Web Vitals (progi Core Web Vitals)
  2. Google Search Central — Build and submit a sitemap
  3. Google Search Central — Introduction to robots.txt
  4. Google Search Central — How HTTP status codes and network errors affect Google Search
  5. Google Search Central — Large site owner's guide to managing your crawl budget
  6. Google Search Central — Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content
  7. Google Search Central — Influencing your title links in search results
  8. Google Search Central — Tell Google about localized versions of your page (hreflang)
  9. Google Search Central — Mobile site and mobile-first indexing best practices
  10. Pomoc Search Console — Raport indeksowania stron (PL)
  11. Search Console Help — Page indexing report (EN)
  12. Google Search Central — Latest documentation updates (FAQ rich results, 2026)
  13. Screaming Frog — SEO Spider (limit wersji darmowej)
  14. Search Console Help — Generative AI performance report (Search)

Need help with this?

We grow rankings in Google and optimise for AI search engines. No “#1 in a week” promises — just Search Console data you can verify.