Websites

How to Choose a Web Design Agency: Questions, Red Flags, Contract

12 min read Updated: Czytaj po polsku
How to Choose a Web Design Agency: Questions, Red Flags, Contract

Choose a web design agency on four things and compare prices last: live projects you can test yourself, a clearly described process (who does what, and when), what you will own once the site is handed over (domain, accounts, code, copyright), and a contract with a defined scope and sign-off procedure. Below you will find the questions to ask on the first call, the red flags to walk away from and the contract clauses you should not skip.

What should you prepare before contacting an agency?

Most web projects that go wrong do so because the client and the agency pictured different things, not because the agency was bad. Send three studios the line “we need a modern website” and you will get three quotes for three different products.

Your brief does not need to be polished. One page answering six questions is enough:

  • Goal: what is the site for? Generating enquiries, selling, hiring, building trust before a sales meeting?
  • Audience: who should land on it, and from where: search, ads, referrals, social media?
  • Scope: list of pages, languages, features (forms, bookings, blog, shop, CRM integration).
  • Content: who writes the copy and supplies photos and video, you or the agency?
  • Budget and deadline: a range, even a wide one, and the date the site has to be live.
  • References: two or three sites you like, with one sentence on why.

If you have no idea what to budget, start with our guide on how much a website costs, which breaks down what drives the price and which costs only show up after launch.

Freelancer, studio or large agency: who are you actually looking for?

There is no single right answer. Match the type of supplier to the size of the project and to how much support you will need after launch.

Supplier Works well for Watch out for
Freelancer Simple brochure sites, small budgets, a fixed and clear scope One person means one point of failure: illness, holidays, a new full-time job. Ask who takes over if they disappear.
Small studio (a handful of people) Company websites, online shops, projects that combine design, development and SEO Check which skills are in-house and which are subcontracted.
Large agency or software house Complex platforms, integrations with internal systems, many stakeholders on the client side Higher project-management overhead. Ask whether the people in the pitch will actually work on your site.
DIY website builder Starting on a minimal budget when you have time to do everything yourself Limited flexibility and harder migration later. Your own time is not free either.

How do you vet a portfolio beyond the screenshots?

A polished mock-up proves someone can design in Figma. It tells you nothing about whether the site loads fast, works on a phone or brings in customers. Ask for links to live projects and spend fifteen minutes testing them.

  1. Open three or four portfolio sites on your phone. Try the menu and the contact form, and check that the text is readable without zooming.
  2. Run them through PageSpeed Insights. Google treats LCP up to 2.5 s, INP up to 200 ms and CLS up to 0.1 as good, measured at the 75th percentile of visits (web.dev, Core Web Vitals). If the tool shows real-user data, look at that before the lab test.
  3. Check the site still looks like the portfolio entry. A project from five years ago, since rebuilt by someone else, says little about the current team.
  4. Ask to speak to one or two clients. Ask about communication, deadlines and what happened after launch.
  5. Look for range. If every project looks like a sibling of the others, expect the same template in different colours.

A good portfolio covers different industries. Ours includes velaro-rent.com (car rental) and viptransfercracow.pl (VIP transfers in Kraków); you can open and test both before you ever get in touch, and the rest is in our portfolio.

Which questions should you ask on the first call?

The first call is a test of communication. What matters is not only the answers but whether the agency explains things plainly and asks about your business. An agency that quotes a price without a single question about the site’s goal is pricing a template, not your project.

Question Good answer Warning sign
Who exactly will work on my site? Names and roles: designer, developer, content/SEO person, project lead “Our team” with no names; subcontractors you hear about later
Which platform will you use, and why? A choice justified by your needs, e.g. WordPress, an established e-commerce platform or a custom build A proprietary, closed CMS that the site cannot be moved off
Whose name will the domain and hosting be in? Yours; the agency gets access The agency’s, “because it’s easier”
How many rounds of revisions are included? A specific number for design and for build “Unlimited revisions”, which sounds generous and ends in an argument
How does sign-off work, and how long do I have to report bugs? A written acceptance step, a window for feedback, a warranty period for fixes No procedure; “just give us a call”
What about SEO at launch and when moving from the old site? 301 redirects, XML sitemap, meta tags, structured data, Search Console set-up “SEO is included” with no list of what that means
Who writes the copy and sources the images? A clear split; if the agency, how much copy and where images come from Placeholder text right up to launch day
What happens after launch? A separate maintenance offer: updates, backups, response times “Websites don’t break”
Will I get full admin access and the code? Yes, at handover or on payment of the final invoice Editor-level login only, no server access
Which licences will you buy on my behalf? A list: theme, plugins, fonts, stock images, and whose name each is in No idea where the images came from

Red flags: when to say thanks and walk away

Google itself lists several warning signs in its guide to hiring an SEO (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). They apply just as much to agencies selling “a website with SEO included”.

  • Guaranteed rankings. Google puts it bluntly: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” If someone promises the top spot, Google’s advice is to find someone else.
  • Cold outreach. The same guide tells you to be wary of firms that email you out of the blue.
  • Secrecy. An agency that cannot explain in plain words what it is going to do either does not know or does not want you to know.
  • Domain or Analytics in the agency’s name. If you part ways, you can lose your web address and your entire data history.
  • 100% upfront. A fair structure ties payments to milestones: deposit, design approval, launch.
  • A one-line quote. “Company website: £X” with no pages, features or revision count is a recipe for extra invoices.
  • No questions about your business. If nobody asks about your customers, competitors and goals, you will get a pretty brochure that sells nothing.
  • Artificial urgency. A “discount valid until Friday” on a design project usually means the agency needs the work more than you need them.

What should a website design contract include?

The contract’s main job is to pin down exactly what will be built and when the work counts as finished. These are the clauses not to sign without. Treat this as a checklist, not legal advice; on larger projects, have a lawyer read the contract.

Clause What it should cover Why it matters
Scope Pages, features, languages, integrations, ideally in a specification annex Anything outside scope is a paid change, and you want to know that upfront
Timeline Milestones, dates, and what you must deliver and by when Delays on your side move the deadline, which is fair if it is written down
Payments Amounts tied to milestones You never pay for something that does not exist yet
Acceptance Procedure, feedback window, sign-off document, what happens if no feedback arrives Without it, “are we done yet?” can drag on for months
Intellectual property Assignment of rights to the design, code and content; the scope of use; the right to modify; when the rights pass to you Without it, you may not be free to change your own website
Third-party licences Theme, plugins, fonts, images: who is the licensee, who pays for renewals The agency cannot assign these to you; it can only buy them in your name
Warranty How long, and what, the agency fixes for free A bug found a month after launch should not become a new project
Maintenance A separate agreement: updates, backups, monitoring, response times A site left without updates gradually develops security and stability issues
Personal data A data processing agreement if the agency hosts the site or can access form submissions As the data controller, you are responsible for your customers’ data

Copyright: get it in writing

Paying for a website does not automatically make you the owner of its copyright. In most jurisdictions an assignment has to be written down:

  • United States: under 17 U.S.C. § 204(a), a transfer of copyright ownership is not valid unless it is in writing and signed by the owner of the rights (U.S. Copyright Office, Title 17, Chapter 2).
  • United Kingdom: section 90(3) of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 says an assignment “is not effective unless it is in writing signed by or on behalf of the assignor” (legislation.gov.uk).
  • Poland (relevant if you hire a Polish studio such as ours under Polish law): Article 53 of the Copyright Act requires written form on pain of nullity (Art. 53), the transfer covers only the fields of use expressly listed (Art. 41(2)), and the right to authorise adaptations stays with the author unless the contract says otherwise (Art. 46).

Practical takeaway: the contract should name the design, code and content, list how you may use them, explicitly allow modifications by anyone you choose, and state when the rights pass to you, typically on final payment. If you are in the EU or UK and the agency hosts your site or handles form data, Article 28 GDPR also requires a written processing agreement (GDPR, EUR-Lex).

What should you own once the project is finished?

A good agency keeps clients through service, not by holding their website hostage. After handover, check that you have:

  • The domain, registered to your company, with your own login at the registrar.
  • The hosting account in your name, or a clause stating how and how fast the agency will move the site to your server.
  • Full admin access to the CMS and, for custom builds, to the code repository.
  • Your own Google Search Console and Analytics properties, with the agency added as a user. Google even advises giving an SEO read-only access during an audit (Google Search Central).
  • A licence list with renewal dates, plus a current backup.

Technology matters here too. According to W3Techs, WordPress runs 57.5% of websites whose CMS can be identified and 38.5% of all websites (W3Techs, data as of 18 November 2026). A site built on a widely used open platform means you can easily find someone else to take it over. An agency’s in-house CMS usually leaves two options: stay, or rebuild from scratch.

SEO, speed and accessibility: what to ask before launch

A new site that goes live without redirects from the old URLs can lose years of search traffic within days. If you are replacing an existing site, ask for a 301 redirect map (old URL → new URL) before launch, and check that structured data, an XML sitemap and Search Console are part of the job.

Speed is a requirement, not an extra. Put it in the specification that the site must pass Core Web Vitals thresholds on mobile. We explain how to get there in our guide to Core Web Vitals and site speed.

If you sell online in the EU, ask about accessibility. The European Accessibility Act covers e-commerce (European Commission); in Poland, the implementing law has applied since 28 June 2025, with services provided by microenterprises exempt (gov.pl). Whoever builds your shop should know whether these rules apply to you and what that means for the design.

How to compare quotes, step by step

  1. Send the same brief to three to five agencies. More quotes mean more comparison work, not necessarily a better choice.
  2. Drop quotes with no scope. If you cannot tell what you are getting, you cannot tell what you are paying for.
  3. Compare side by side: scope, timeline, revisions, warranty, maintenance, copyright, and who owns the domain and accounts.
  4. Test two or three projects from each shortlist agency as described above, and call one of their clients.
  5. Book a call with your top two and work through the question table. Notice who asks questions and who just sells.
  6. Only now compare prices. The cheapest quote, without aftercare or copyright, is often the most expensive one a year later.
  7. Read the contract before signing and tick off the clauses above one by one.

Want to put us through the same test? Send us your brief and you will get a proposal with a detailed scope, timeline and copyright terms. See how we approach website design and development and SEO and GEO, which we plan alongside the build rather than bolting on after launch.

Got a brief, or just an idea? Get in touch via our contact page or at biuro@orbitbuilder.pl. We will reply with questions about your business, not a price list.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if a web design agency is trustworthy?

Ask for links to three or four live projects and test them on your phone and in PageSpeed Insights. Call one of their clients and ask about deadlines and post-launch support. A trustworthy agency will also tell you, without hesitation, exactly who will work on your site.

Who should own the domain name of my business website?

Your company should be the registrant, with its own login at the registrar. The agency can be given access to manage DNS, but it should not own the domain. A domain registered to the agency makes it much harder to switch suppliers.

Do I automatically own the copyright to a website I paid for?

Not necessarily. In the US and the UK, a copyright assignment must be in writing and signed, and Polish law requires written form on pain of nullity. Make sure the contract explicitly assigns the rights to the design, code and content and allows you to modify them.

Can an agency guarantee a first-page or #1 ranking on Google?

No. Google’s Search Central documentation states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking and advises finding someone else if an agency makes that promise. A credible agency will explain what it plans to do and how it will measure results.

How many quotes should I get for a new website?

Three to five is usually enough. What matters most is sending everyone the same brief, so you can compare scope, timeline, sign-off terms and aftercare first, and price last.

What should I receive when my website is handed over?

Full admin access, a current backup, a list of licences with renewal dates and a signed acceptance document. The warranty period for bug fixes starts at this point. If the site needs ongoing updates and monitoring, put a separate maintenance agreement in place straight away.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
  2. web.dev: Web Vitals (progi LCP, INP, CLS)
  3. Ustawa o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych, art. 53 (Standardy Prawa)
  4. Ustawa o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych, art. 41 (Standardy Prawa)
  5. Ustawa o prawie autorskim i prawach pokrewnych, art. 46 (Standardy Prawa)
  6. Rozporządzenie (UE) 2016/679 (RODO/GDPR), EUR-Lex
  7. W3Techs: Usage statistics of WordPress (18 listopada 2026)
  8. gov.pl: Polski Akt o Dostępności — usługi handlu elektronicznego
  9. U.S. Copyright Office: Title 17, Chapter 2 (§ 204)
  10. legislation.gov.uk: Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, s. 90
  11. European Commission: European Accessibility Act

Need help with this?

We design and code company websites from scratch — no off-the-shelf templates, built for conversion, speed and visibility in Google and AI search.